Skip to main content

This Black Civil Rights Commissioner Actually Sent Letter to Senator Asking for Tougher Sentences for African-American Men

May 12, 2016 | Posted by
Tagged With: , ,

Peter Kirsanow. C-Span.

Peter Kirsanow. C-Span.

A member of the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights condemned a bill that would reduce jail sentences, arguing that it would lead to an increase in crime for African-American communities.

In a letter addressed to Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa), Commissioner Peter Kirsanow makes his case against the Sentencing Reform Act of 2015.

“Three years ago, the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights held a briefing on the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission’s [EEOC] revised guidance on the use of criminal background checks in hiring,” he wrote. “The guidance was motivated by many of the same concerns that seem to underlie the Sentencing Reform Act – primarily that minority men, particularly African-American men, are disproportionately likely to be incarcerated and have criminal records, a concern about burgeoning prison populations, and a sense that as a society we should focus on rehabilitation, not retribution.”

Kirsanow said the commission heard witnesses testify to the hardships faced by ex-convicts when looking for jobs, which he acknowledged was “a very real and troubling concern.” But he said the briefing was misleading, giving the impression that rehabilitation was common for ex-offenders and that ex-offenders were no different than the average non-offender.


“People who are convicted of a crime and imprisoned are a very small minority of the U.S. population – according to the EEOC, they comprise approximately 6.6 percent of the population. These people have managed to be less law-abiding than the remaining 93.4 percent of the U.S. population – quite a feat. It is perhaps less of a feat when one considers that many offenders have serious additional problems that likely incline them toward criminality.”

He cited Dr. Matt Delisi’s testimony at a 2013 Senate Judiciary hearing. DeLisi said ex-convicts show signs of psychopathy at a rate at least “25-fold” higher than the general public and testified, “releasing 1% of the current BOP [Bureau of Prisons] population would result in approximately 37,230 additional murders rapes [sic], robberies, aggravated assaults, burglaries, thefts, auto thefts, and incidents of arson.”

Delisi said there was not enough reliable evidence to support the advantages of rehabilitation because most studies fail to control for selection bias.

For this reason, Kirsanow wrote, sentencing should be handled on an individual basis, by judges and parole officers with better knowledge of the offender and crime.

And Kirsanow said the issue directly affects him, as he lives in a “high-crime, predominantly African-American neighborhood” in inner-city Cleveland.

“For my neighbors and me, these concerns are not remote. When these men are released from prison earlier than they otherwise would have been, they are coming back to my neighborhood and neighborhoods like mine. You cannot wish away the deleterious consequences of releasing unreformed criminals when they are released into your own neighborhood.”

In short, because it is too difficult to predict which ex-offenders are less likely to repeat crimes or benefit from rehabilitation, the solution is to keep them incarcerated for as long as possible for the greater good of the Black community.

In an email to the Atlanta Black Star, Kirsanow’s personal assistant Carissa Mulder confirmed the commissioner sent the letter on May 5.

Who is Peter Kirsanow and how did he end up on the Commission?

The Cleveland labor and employment attorney seems an unlikely candidate for the independent, bipartisan federal agency charged with “appraising the laws and policies of the Federal Government with respect to equal protection of the laws under the Constitution,” according to the Civil Rights Act of 1957.

He strongly opposes affirmative action in higher education. In fact, the late Justice Antonin Scalia made reference to one of Kirsanow’s briefs during his infamous remarks about Black college students benefiting from “less advanced,” “slower-track schools where they do well.” In the brief, Kirsanow and fellow commissioner Gail Heriot argued that the policy deters African-American students from choosing STEM majors. Those who do often graduate from less reputable universities, the brief said.

He does not support the Black Lives Matter movement. Kirsanow appeared on a Heritage Foundation panel to discuss the Supreme Court’s University of Texas vs. Fisher case in 2015. There, he denounced BLM protestors as “precious little flowers,” according to The Huffington Post.

“They are these precious little flowers that believe they’ve been discriminated against, 50 years after passage of the 1964 Civil Rights Act,” he said. “It is incredible what we’re countenancing here.”

He then criticized the concept of white privilege.

“I keep hearing about white privilege. The most privileged students in schools in 2015 America are Hispanic and Black students by far,” he said at the discussion.

The Atlanta Black Star reported on the complaint he filed with the U.S. Department of Education against the University of Connecticut. University officials planned to set aside a campus dormitory wing for Black male students. Kirsanow slammed the action as “Orwellian” and “promoting the ‘ghettoization’ of Black males.”

“Universities are not places for ethnic navel-gazing, they should be places where our intellects are broadened, where our comforts are challenged, where our interactions include those who do not look or think like us,” he said in a feature for Education Dive.

His nomination to the Commission by President George W. Bush was met with fierce opposition from left-leaning leaders and organizations. They fought his appointment all the way to the Supreme Court, with Chairwoman Mary Frances Berry telling White House counsel Alberto Gonzales he would need “federal marshals” to seat him.

Today Kirsanow is the longest-serving member on the Commission.









"I'm just trying to make a way out of no way, for my people" -Modejeska Monteith Simpkins









Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Perhaps Mr. Kirsanow could experience a 3 month tryout in one of the cages in the basement of San Quentin prison. Spend a couple months in one of those two man cells where you can hardly move, where you urinate and defecate in front of one another with hardly any room to breathe. May he suffer the worst case of claustrophobia imaginable.

He could practice being a dog or any other animal they equate black men with by locking them up in those basement cages that one can hardly stand up; lining the entire floor of the basement. So Zoo-like. Maybe he'll change his mind. He looks like he has a white parent; that's probably the side that's doing the wishing for longer sentences. A Black White man 'tis all. If all of us were locked up, he'd crack the whip.

Last edited by Norland

Brotha RR wrote:  White People can't solve Black people's problems....White People have only added problems to our community, why would expect them to subtract them?

  As why it is NOW important to do things ourselves....we got the POWER and the MONEY.  But it ain't gon do no good if many of us STILL have our heads up massa's ass.  I know it's difficult to start trusting each other....cuz of it being SNATCHED from our soul during the Atlantic Slavery Trade and Jim Crow...the brainwashing of black geniuses....but!  We gotta BELIEVE what we say but ACTION....that is the only way we can regain UNITY.  Lately all I've seen is angry black people....toward each other....always got something focked up or negative to say...with many of the things they are spewing is as a result social frustration.  But we STILL have the ability to shift that.  And do it case by case.  Cuz some black folks I DON'T WANNA ENGAGE with because of the backward ignorant self-hating conditioning that is ingrain in their psyche.  Like racists we have to just let the universe handle them as we REBUILD our culture.  And it is it and they will come.  So we got to get to work...engaging in convo, kindness and black pride.  We gotta do this before it's TOO LATE.  But!

Black people actually learning their own TRUE history, eliminating the housenigger factor, and getting Black people to stop bowing down worshipping the 'Golden Calf' of [Western] Materialism would solve at least 90% of the problems facing the Black race, here in America, and globally.  

BLACK UNIFICATION would automatically evaporate the remaining 10%. 


Momentum posted:

Wow, this is the era of the full blown power establishment backed COON!

Certainly offers a window into how it was that the Black race fell from the FIRST and HIGHEST Civilization, [the Civilization "closest to the Gods"], to where we are now.  

[Being stabbed in the back (repeatedly) for 30 Pieces of Silver, by our own, who were only looking out themselves]





Add Reply

Link copied to your clipboard.