quote:
Originally posted by negrospiritual:
Back to the drawing board...
quote:
Originally posted by Khalliqa:
I would like suggestions of how to deal with those of us who have irresponsible fathers... who have abusive fathers.. or just bad men in their lives...
quote:
There is becoming a disconnect.. those who are fathers are becoming irritated by the negative expressions of those who are bitter about theirs and are wishing them to at least on fathers day say something positive...
couple a questions:
1. Is the pain of those who are fathers any less valid than the pain of those who are bitter?
I rarely if ever try to measure pain against pain to see which is better.. It's like the Affirmative Action issue.. Is the pain of a white individual whose worked hard and is losing out on a very good opportunity... to fulfill a quota as valid as the person who experiences pain when they are qualified for a position but denied because of the color of their skin... I think there are historical and other issues of justice that come into play when evaluating what should be done.. even as I can't say that a white person's pain is more or less valid..
Individually I can not say... and would feel terrible trying to ... collectively I wouldn't couch it as a pain issue.. I would couch it in its historical and collective scope.. and try to solve the problem rather than try to figure out who has a right to their pain.. we all do.. the question is how will we approach life with one another... when our experiences and desires run counter to one another... Historically, we're a different people.. with different upbringing, expectations and sense of justice... and this plays a part.. as well as how things happen collectively v. personally... but I digress..
I think that the norm and the more stable of the two should be willing to be empathetic with a growing problem in our community.. that doesn't make anyone's pain more or less valid.. it simply seems to me that the stronger of the two should yield to understanding and tolerance...
Again.. of course this precludes someone THROWING it in their faces.. however, someone experiencing what for them is a reality should not generate such anger.. like Malik's post.. He wants to celebrate and admits he can't be empathetic.. well that works for him and you can't MAKE a person be empathetic.. but it certainly would help...
It seems weird to ask the more damaged of the two to be more happy than it does to ask the stronger of the two to be more empathetic... or solution oriented... I suppose like being charitable on Christmas... where you recognize there are children who are sad.. whose sadness does not mean they wish YOU an ill Christmas, just that they do not have the means to participate jovially in the day... so we give gifts.. or try to remember those less fortunate... We don't demand the poor recognize our own good fortune.. We express empathy for those on Thanksgiving... We express empathy for those lonely on Valentines Day and write articles to help alleviate the pain of those who do not have loved ones.. we do not take it personally that they are not celebrating OUR love.. or someone else's love.. somehow we intuitively understand their sorrow and sometimes hurt.. and despair as a LONGING for love... We tend to interpret people's pain from loss or trauma of family as a personal attack however... and do not see them as longing.. we interpret their anger and hurt as trying to rain on our parade...
quote:
2. Are people in that very specific scenario described in the OP being encouraged to say something positive and therefore false about their own deadbeat dad? or something that affirms/honors fatherhood in general?
No... It was a question that began that way and when queried further as I understood how people are taking the question .. I realized I must simplify it even further and try to remove it from anyone feeling like this is strictly personal and I will RESTATE that my intent is simply for us to come up with solutions to bridge the gap that are realistic.. and after my last post I'm only addressing you out of respect for you.. because I've concluded that it isn't possible...
quote:
3. Is this perceived disconnect displayed in conversations between 2 invididuals (on a personal discussion level) or when public officials make broad sweeping indictments of black fathers (for ex. 2 bookclub members discussing their feelings about their no good dads VS. a public official making the no good nigga speech in public venues, articles and on television)
Whereever the disparate attitudes are present.. in personal or public conversation.. the point is the attitude not the venue necessarily..
The point was mentioned early on that no one likes to have PAIN thrust in their face.. so I conceded that if someone is aggressively raining on your parade.. by all means leave.. but for other scenarios where it is discussed as a serious communal problem.. whether someone expresses it personally or whether it is discussed publicly.. or even where someone is asked.. or someone is venting directed at no one in particular... (either way) how do you bridge the gap...? So far, the one consistent answer I've received is basically there is NO bridging the gap.. because there is lack of empathy for anyone who can't celebrate on that day.. The only answer is for them to STOP feeling pain and/or allowing their pain to affect them and celebrate... to me that's not a solution that's an unrealistic and unsympathetic Order.. and so thus there is no solution...
quote:
quote:
What do you think about this suggestion?
What was the suggestion that posters were to share their thoughts about? The suggestion that there is a disconnect? or The request for suggestions on how to deal?
It was written awkwardly.. but the point.. is to receive suggestions on what to do about the growing tension centered around Father's Day with those who are able to celebrate and particularly those who HAVE someone to celebrate in their midst and those who do not.. or find that they can not participate... and the growing frustration of the former with the latter... I've only heard the call for others to shut up about their experiences so I was asking if
1. This is how THIS board feels... -which I've received a YES
2. If so, if there is anything that can be done to bridge the gap of understanding.. so our community won't be torn apart on this day- ? I've received a NO..those who've had negative experiences need to be silenced on this day so that others can be happy
3. If not, where does our community go from here? - I've concluded that going forward there will be a wider disconnect.. and more of one camp looking down and being irritated with the other which in turn will began to cause resentment.. which in turn will be one more issue that tears at any attempts at unity within our community... Because as it stands now frequent salutations on Father's Day are turning into these variations (real examples
verbatim culled from facebook sent to out to everyone) and received flak from others who wished people would express positive messages without making mention of those who do not without getting into again this guy sums up the backlash from the following statements "is hoping that we can have a nice Father's Day without all of the absentee father bashing and wishing "Happy Father's Day to mothers who are doing the job of both parents." Mother's Day was in May. Let us have ONE day."
Here are a small snippet of some of the statements that received backlash:
"Happy Father's to all the REAL Father's out there"
"Happy Father's Day to Father's and Not Sperm Donors"
"A Father is a man who is responsible, not someone who is a sperm donor"
"hopes that all Father's had a wonderful day. Father's day isn't really an easy time for me, but thought about ya'll all day, and it helped. Thanks for being such wonderful Daddy's to your kids!"
"There are few tough guys these days they on death row,shot on a hotel balcony, point blank with shot gun pellets, on his doorstep in his wife's arms, at 4am while he slept in his bed with his woman; now-even the gangsters have been taught to shuffle with cough syrup,videos,chinese rifles and block grants, while our families are being torn apart...happy fathers day gentlemen.Protect our babies- teach them to read!"- From a Famous Person on fathers Day
"Happy Father's Day to all the brothers who are being a Father to their child!"
"Happy Fathers day to all the dads that r actually DADS!!"
"Happy Fathers Day to all fathers not sperm donors..." (twice)
"I wish I could give my dad a best father's day award. I guess he did the best he knew how but boy...if that was his best. I'd hate to see if he didn't give a shyt....(*kicks rocks)....... PS My daughter thinks he's dead (not by anything I've told her...but b/c she's only seen him like once or twice and she's 5) For the ladies who grew up with a dad who was present and accounted for.....hug him tight (for me)."
"Happy Fathers Day fellas and ladies who are doing the double duty."
"Good morning all... Happy Fathers Day to all of the Real Fathers and Legal Guardians "
"Happy Father's Day to all the men who are holding their kids up by doing right by them (biological ones & others) and hoping this day will wake up so many of those who are not...."
"Happy Father's Day to my Husband (and father of 4)....and to all the Fathers (and Mothers acting as Fathers) out there holdin' it down for your own clans."
"is grateful for everyone & everything in my life including all you silly Facebookers. If your earthly father is absent, far away or passed on spend today with the One who is a father of the fatherless and a defender of widows because is God in ALWAYS His holy dwelling (Psalm 68:5). Have a wonderful Father's Day out there!"
Some are more harsh than others.. but all received some sort of backlash...
For everyone of these messages that received backlash.. there were messages that were only positive.... usually about that person's own father.. or their husband..
Like this one: "Happy Father's Day to all the stand up Dads out there. I'm proud to know and have known many of you! Love and miss you, Daddy "
This is just on Facebook.. doesn't include Twitter.. personal phone messages... other website debates.. etc... I've just noticed a growing disconnect.. that's all.. and wondered how people like the brother who asked for his ONE day was going to make all of these other people who recognize that Father's Day is difficult to celebrate change so he can have his one day?
I only see those who think like him growing more and more frustrated.. and those who they are upset with growing more and more frustrated as well...
disclaimer: This isn't about the ONE guy I quoted.. This isn't about the FEW statements I've quoted.. This isn't about ME.. This isn't about what only I've experienced.. This is about ALL of it (us).. because it is a shared attitude that looks like it's going to get worse.. and it is beyond Father's Day to me in many ways.. because it is reflective of the different familial experiences we have and how we perceive one another... and what this is going to do to the community in the future...
Again, hopefully someone will take up the issue at a later time whose persona is not so polarizing so people on this board will not become so fixated on possible motive...
Take care... (I'm taking down their comments in a few days.. I just wanted to flesh out and bring an example of what I've been witnessing around me )