Castro is on his last few breaths, he's very ill. he'll pass his dictatorship on to that clown brother of his, and within months Cuba will become a democratic nation.
Another one bites the dust.
Original Post
Replies sorted oldest to newest
quote:Originally posted by MBM:
Just out of curiosity, which country do you think has oppressed more people, Democratic United States or Communist Cuba?
quote:But when the economy began recovering in the late 1990s, Castro reasserted control and stifled private business.
quote:Originally posted by Empty Purnata:
US of course. And it's REPUBLIC of the United States, not "Democratic".
quote:Originally posted by MBM:quote:Originally posted by Empty Purnata:
US of course. And it's REPUBLIC of the United States, not "Democratic".
We're a Republican Democracy, no? A republic is the type of democratic government that we have.
![]()
quote:Originally posted by MBM:
Just out of curiosity, which country do you think has oppressed more people, Democratic United States or Communist Cuba?
quote:Originally posted by Momentum:
Yes or No question:
Did Castro imprison a whole nation of people under his dictatorship?
quote:Moral equivalences are used to deflect criticism, in this case Castro who is a totalitarian dictator of which he regulated nearly every aspect of public and private life.
quote:Just because the US has done terrible wrongs does not mean that Castro's dictatorship is alright. These kinds of arguments are a claim that is no moral baseline to discern right and wrong.
Are you advocating that dictatorship is a good thing?
quote:Originally posted by Empty Purnata:quote:Originally posted by Momentum:
Yes or No question:
Did Castro imprison a whole nation of people under his dictatorship?
No. Cuban citizens are free to leave Cuba any time they wish. Cuba allows emigration on the terms that the emigrants have no outstanding debts to the state (such as deserting military serivices or credit debts). The ones who aren't allowed to leave are the ones with some sort of outstanding debt.
The US on the other hand allows no America to emigrate to Cuba under ANY circumstance.quote:Moral equivalences are used to deflect criticism, in this case Castro who is a totalitarian dictator of which he regulated nearly every aspect of public and private life.
Castro is a dictator, but he's an authoritarian dictator, not totalitarian. His predecessor, Batista, was much more brutal. Whom the US had no problem backing.
Castro is no more regulating Cubans' aspect of public and private life than our government (which has taken to spying, wire-tapping, allowing the police to enter without knocking, regularly violates International law and implants low-jack chips in cell phones).quote:Just because the US has done terrible wrongs does not mean that Castro's dictatorship is alright. These kinds of arguments are a claim that is no moral baseline to discern right and wrong.
Are you advocating that dictatorship is a good thing?
No one here is. We're just not pretending that Castro is the Devil incarnate while the US is a mere flawed mortal. Cuba is far less dangerous than the US, and Castro really isn't much more authoritarian than our own government.
Having an election every 4 years doesn't make you democratic. An election which is more symbolic than anything. The Electoral College and lobbyists on K Street decides Presidents, not the American citizens.
quote:Originally posted by Oshun Auset:quote:Originally posted by Empty Purnata:quote:Originally posted by Momentum:
Yes or No question:
Did Castro imprison a whole nation of people under his dictatorship?
No. Cuban citizens are free to leave Cuba any time they wish. Cuba allows emigration on the terms that the emigrants have no outstanding debts to the state (such as deserting military serivices or credit debts). The ones who aren't allowed to leave are the ones with some sort of outstanding debt.
The US on the other hand allows no America to emigrate to Cuba under ANY circumstance.quote:Moral equivalences are used to deflect criticism, in this case Castro who is a totalitarian dictator of which he regulated nearly every aspect of public and private life.
Castro is a dictator, but he's an authoritarian dictator, not totalitarian. His predecessor, Batista, was much more brutal. Whom the US had no problem backing.
Castro is no more regulating Cubans' aspect of public and private life than our government (which has taken to spying, wire-tapping, allowing the police to enter without knocking, regularly violates International law and implants low-jack chips in cell phones).quote:Just because the US has done terrible wrongs does not mean that Castro's dictatorship is alright. These kinds of arguments are a claim that is no moral baseline to discern right and wrong.
Are you advocating that dictatorship is a good thing?
No one here is. We're just not pretending that Castro is the Devil incarnate while the US is a mere flawed mortal. Cuba is far less dangerous than the US, and Castro really isn't much more authoritarian than our own government.
Having an election every 4 years doesn't make you democratic. An election which is more symbolic than anything. The Electoral College and lobbyists on K Street decides Presidents, not the American citizens.
![]()
quote:Originally posted by Kweli4Real:
E.P., you're on it. But it pains me that more americans in general, and Black [american] folk are so restricted in their worldview that they continue to view Cuba, through the eyes of McCarthy, disposed Cuba "refugees", and FoxNews.![]()
quote:Originally posted by Momentum:
While most Cubans would jump at a chance to come to the states you make moral equivalences to deflect from the reality of why Cubans would leave in droves, probably up to 70 percent of the people.
quote:You argue the States is no better than Cuba while you could leave at anytime you want if you are in debt or not. You can burn the flag, speak out against US government, call Bush names in public and not fear becoming a political prisoner like they do in Cuba.
quote:You make an argument that the differences of Cuban freedom are marginal compared to ours in the States.
The differences are so brutally obvious it's not worth debating.
quote:Originally posted by Empty Purnata:
I bet the COINTELLPRO just put this post I made in the permanent files on their computers.......
quote:Originally posted by Oshun Auset:
EP, you've been had a file by now!
quote:You know what also really erks me about the way we(as is Africans in Amerikkka) view Cuba in mass... We never deal with the racial/economic factors. Like how Castro actually payed government reparations to the MAJORITY Afro-Cuban population and attempted to redistribute the wealth by giving a double income salary to Afro-cubans for 25 years after the revolution(Castos mother was a mulatto, I think that had something to do with it). Notice how the majority of the Cuban expatriots in the U.S. are of European descent, that is no coincidence, they were the one's with the money and 'capitol' after slavery was abolished. Now Cuba is some 65% African.
quote:We also never deal with all of the contributions to the African revolution and African development that Cuba has made. They backed with troops Guinea-Bissau's War of Independence. As well as Angola, Mozambique, the D.R.C.(Zaire) and the Anti Apartheid struggle. There have been so many doctors and teachers sent to Africa I have yet to run into a continental African who wasn't taught be a Cuban in school.
So once again, who's interests are we backing?
quote:On a side note you can now legally travel to Cuba, you just can't spend money there. But there are communal places to stay where you can work off your room and board. I can't wait!
quote:Originally posted by JanesT:
Castro is on his last few breaths, he's very ill. he'll pass his dictatorship on to that clown brother of his, and within months Cuba will become a democratic nation.
Another one bites the dust.